In the realm of IT service provision, accurately defining the scope of a contract is crucial for determining liability. The Paris Commercial Court, in its decision dated October 4, 2023, underlined the significance of precisely delineating the services included and excluded in such contracts.

Case Study: Ambiguity in Scope in Web Contracts

The case in question involved a company that hired an IT service provider for migrating its e-commerce website. The migration process encountered significant issues, resulting in damage to the website’s module, data corruption, and adversely affecting the site's natural search rankings.

The client alleged that the service provider failed to meet its contractual obligations. However, the court found that the contract did not explicitly cover certain technical aspects like "front-end slowness" or "Search Engine Optimization (SEO)." The court concluded that the service provider was not at fault as these services were either declined by the customer or not specifically included in the contract.

This case underscores the potential pitfalls in web contract drafting, particularly the lack of specificity about excluded services.

The Need for Aligning Customer Expectations with Contractual Terms

Customers may have expectations for enhancements or services that are not typically included in standard contracts. These additional services, requiring specific technical interventions, are often not part of a standard migration contract. This discrepancy can lead to customer dissatisfaction and frustration.

Therefore, it is imperative to align the contract with the customer’s understanding and needs. This involves transparent communication, in line with article 1112-1 of the French Civil Code. Clear definition of exclusions and realistic customer expectations within the web contract is essential.

For comprehensive clarity, contracts should explicitly list all services that are not included but are available from the service provider.

Benefits of This Contractual Approach

This method of contract drafting aims to:

• 1. Inform the customer adequately about the service provider's liability limits.
• 2. Shield the service provider from unwarranted breach of duty accusations.
• 3. Prevent conflicts arising from miscommunication or unmet expectations.
• 4. Foster trust and transparency between the involved parties.
• 5. Clarify additional services and pricing, thereby highlighting the service provider’s expertise.

In conclusion, effective contractual drafting in IT services, particularly regarding scope and exclusions, is paramount for both customer satisfaction and provider protection.

Our IT Contracts, Data & Compliance Department is ready to assist .

For inquiries, please feel free to reach out.